Apollo is able to dance on banking’s grave | USAEMALL.com

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.

Sometimes a new partnership might really be a passing of the torch. Last week, Apollo said it would work with Citigroup to originate $25bn of leveraged loans, most typically used in leveraged buyouts. More precisely, Apollo would bring the cash and Citi would find the deals among its vast Rolodex.

It was the boldest private credit/bank tie-up yet and also a portent. On Tuesday, Apollo held its investor day session which seemed to be both an exultation and a manifesto, where it declared it would become the “next generation financial services business”.

A generation ago that champion was Citi, the financial supermarket if not superpower. The towering edifice constructed by Sandy Weill by mid-2007 had an equity value of $270bn. Its 4.5 per cent return on equity in 2023, was about quarter of that profitability reached in 2006.

And nearly 20 years later, Citi’s market cap is down to just $120bn. As for the ostensible next-gen Apollo, it has now soared to $70bn. If it hits the five-year targets it put out on Tuesday, it will not be long until it surpasses Citi. In one presentation slide, Apollo appeared to have already prepared a tombstone for the bulge bracket era, writing that the era of “banks/capital markets” lived only between 1990 and 2020.

The key year in that 30-year reign for banks is 2008. After the financial crisis, Citi and others simply would not be allowed by regulators to be assertive investors. That left the field open for asset managers, particularly those that wanted to not just manage money but take balance sheet risk like the banking sector of yesteryear.

Apollo says it should soon double assets managed, to $1.5tn, taking money from not just typical institutional capital but also retirement savers and wealthy individuals. That is supposed to generate by 2029 a healthy $9bn of net income split roughly evenly between asset management fees and net interest income.

At a 15 times multiple, that implies an Apollo market capitalisation of $135bn, roughly double Apollo’s current value. The firm pointed out that nearly all the value creation in public financial services stocks in the past decade had come from only the listed “alternative asset” managers.

The Citi of 18 years ago also seemed inexorable and unstoppable but ultimately was undone by a toxic balance sheet and an erratic funding model. The latter is less of an issue for Apollo.

There have been no major blow-ups so far, with a credit downturn yet to appear and central banks continuing to prop up asset valuations. Yet private asset investing sometimes feels too good to be true, with companies and securities in complex forms seemingly just passed among friends at higher and higher values.

Eras in financial services always end or recede with the incumbents always the last to find out.

sujeet.indap@ft.com