Stepfather leaves Bahamas after lacking spouse case, daughter skeptical | UNW

The daughter of the American woman missing in The Bahamas says she thinks Brian Hooker is using his mother’s illness as an “excuse” to leave the island nation after he spent five days in a Freeport jail.

Karli Aylesworth told Fox News Digital on Friday that Hooker’s mother has been “terminally ill for a while.” Hooker abruptly left The Bahamas on Wednesday after saying he would remain in the country to search for his missing wife, Aylesworth’s mother, Lynette.

He was released from a Bahamian jail on Monday night after five days behind bars, and made that promise in interviews with news outlets on Tuesday morning.

“He wants to continue with the search for his wife, because that is his main focus,” his attorney, Terrel Butler, told Fox News Digital on Tuesday. “So as long as he can remain in the Bahamas, he’ll remain in the Bahamas.”

Karli Aylesworth and her partner Steven arrive in Marsh Harbour, The Bahamas, Thursday, April 16, 2025. Karli is the daughter of missing American woman, Lynette Hooker. (Matthew Symons for NY Post)

FRIEND OF BRIAN HOOKER SPEAKS OUT, QUESTIONS DISAPPEARANCE OF WOMAN IN BAHAMAS MYSTERY

But about 24 hours later, Hooker changed his mind.

“Following his release from custody without charge, Mr. Hooker is now facing another emergency. In addition to the trauma of his wife of 25 years being missing, Mr. Hooker has received urgent word of his mother’s grave illness,” Butler told NBC News on Wednesday afternoon. “He has traveled to [the] United States of America to be at her bedside during this critical time.”

Brian and Lynette Hooker sit on a dinghy in the water in this undated image. (Brian Hooker/Facebook)

Butler did not say where in the U.S. Hooker was going, but a source familiar with the case told Fox News Digital he landed in Atlanta.

COAST GUARD OPENS CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION INTO MISSING WOMAN LAST SEEN IN BAHAMAS

Aylesworth, who arrived in The Bahamas on Thursday, has been critical of her stepfather since her mother Lynette went missing.

“I think it shows his character. He somehow lost my mom at sea and cries on camera saying he’ll never stop searching, then leaves the next day,” Aylesworth told the New York Post upon her arrival to the town of Marsh Harbour, close to where her mother went missing.

LIKE WHAT YOU’RE READING? FIND MORE ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB

General view of the boat “Soulmate,” owned by Brian and Lynette Hooker, in Marsh Harbour, The Bahamas, April 16, 2025. (Matthew Symons for NY Post)

Hooker abandoned the couple’s 40-foot sailboat, called “Soulmate,” anchored near a marina in Marsh Harbour.

The New York Post snapped close-up photos of the idle boat.

Immediately following Lynette’s disappearance, Aylesworth told Fox News Digital she was aware of “prior issues” with Brian’s behavior.

FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X

General views of the inside of “Soulmate,” the boat owned by Brian and Lynette Hooker, in Marsh Harbour, Bahamas, April 16, 2025. Inside the boat are dumbbells and various miscellaneous items. (Matthew Symons for NY Post)

“There have been prior issues brought to my attention, which may be important for any thorough investigation. If this truly was an accident, I can understand and live with it,” Aylesworth said. “However, there needs to be an intensive review of the facts and circumstances of this tragic incident before that can be determined.”

SIGN UP TO GET TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER

She also told “Fox and Friends” that something “doesn’t add up” with her mother’s disappearance, and accused Brian of having a “history of domestic violence” and anger issues.

Brian Hooker stops by the Central Police Station to pick up his wedding ring and watch with his lawyer, Terrel A. Butler in Freeport, The Bahamas, Tuesday, April 14, 2026. His ring, which he is wearing on his pinky, was not with him when he was released from jail last night after being questioned by police in the disappearance of his wife, Lynette Hooker.  (Matthew Symons for Fox News Digital)

Hooker says Lynette’s disappearance was an accident caused by high wind and rough seas. The pair left The Abaco Inn bar on Elbow Cay in their dinghy at dusk on April 4, headed to their anchored sailboat just off the cay’s western coast. The ride was a short one, but Brian said Lynette fell overboard in the choppy waters.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

He has always maintained that he is innocent of wrongdoing, and has not been charged with a crime.

He spent five days in jail — the maximum allowable under Bahamian law — while police investigated. That investigation remains ongoing despite his release.